Supreme Court: severe sanctions upheld for power harassment dressed up as training

On 2 September 2025 the Supreme Court upheld the disciplinary dismissal of one Itoshima City fire officer and a six-month suspension of another for abusing junior staff in the name of training. No injury, no prior discipline and some remorse did not make the sanctions excessive.

Status
Court ruling
Ruling
2 September 2025
Applies to
All employers disciplining managers for harassment; the cases concern public servants

What the court decided

In two judgments the same day, the Supreme Court, Third Petty Bench, reversed the Fukuoka High Court and upheld sanctions imposed in March 2017 by the fire chief of Itoshima City in Fukuoka.

In the first case, a section leader had joined in tying a new recruit to a horizontal bar with rope, making him do pull-ups and leaving him hanging for minutes after he gave out; had pushed and struck him and made him apologise aloud to a piece of equipment. He had already received a written warning for verbal abuse. He was suspended for six months, the maximum. In the second, a unit leader had, over more than ten years, put at least ten subordinates through similar punishing drills and insulted them and their families. He was dismissed.

The High Court had found both sanctions too harsh because no one was seriously hurt, neither officer had prior discipline, and they showed some remorse. The Supreme Court held that the conduct went far beyond any instruction or training, caused fear and humiliation whether or not it injured anyone, and badly damaged the workplace. The need for tough training in fire services did not excuse it.

Why it matters

These are public-sector cases decided under the Local Public Service Act, and private-sector dismissals are tested under the Labour Contract Act. But the Supreme Court has signalled that a long pattern of power harassment can justify the heaviest sanction, and that the absence of injury is not a mitigating factor.

Action for employers

Sources

Spotted an error or a newer figure? Report a correction. We check every report against the source and reply within ten business days.

Get a heads-up before Japan's employment rules change
One email a week before each date you choose, never more than one a day. You confirm by email first and can stop at any time. Privacy · The HR calendar

General information for employers, not legal advice. Dates and thresholds are checked against the sources listed and dated above; confirm anything you act on with a Japanese employment lawyer or a licensed labour and social security attorney.

Spotted an error, or want your organisation featured? Send a correction · Ask to be featured · Contact the editor